LAndE kirjoitti:Eli se minun postini Munterille oli turha?
Ei todellakaan. Mikään ei takaa Mattin ja Alession hyväksyntää säännöille.
Joskin Hobbyspecialistit antoivat ihan lupaavan tunteen.
Alberth kirjoitti:juu voisi olla jonkun raportin paikka että mitä oote saanut aikaseksi että kaikki jotka eivät oo seuraneet keskustelua saa tietää mitä tapahtuu...
Jeps, hyvä idea.
Eli lähetin tässä taannoin todella pitkä viestin GW:lle. Se tulee tässä.
Averren E-mailissaan GW:lle kirjoitti:U needed good reasons, and I´ve tried to explain them, but you just say
> "not
> gonna happen, ´cause he not so good" or something like that.
> Firstly, Èomer: His father is Èomund, who spended his whole life
> fighting
> with orcs and such.
> His descendant of Eorl the Young and Helm Hammerhand.
> Èomer himself has been figthing his whole life, as you said Boromir
> did.
> Boromir is just good, and so is Aragorn (though I wonder why Narsil is
> weaker than Andúril...).
> Èomer is trained by best fighers of Rohan, Théodred and his uncle
> Théoden
> (when Théoden was younger).
> Èomer has spent whole his life in wilds and fields securing borders of
> Rohan.
> He fought in a Helms Depp, I think thats a good experience.
> He fought by the walls of Minas Tirith as general and as a king.
> He was Rohans most trusted and skilled generals with Théodred.
> Saruman made a whole plan for tearing Èomer and Théodred apart from
> each
> other by the battle of Ford (or whatever it is in English).
> I think thats a good reason, why Èomer should be better, at least match
> Gothmog and Imrahil.
> You´ve always told me, that their stats represent their deeds, and
> what did
> Gothmog or Imrahil?
> Èomer killed two Múmaks with a single spear, and rode to aid his
> uncle to
> Helms Deep. In a book he fought whole battle there though.
> In a battle of Pelennor Fields Èomer formed a feared group of three
> with
> Aragorn and Imrahil and they were described as equal by Tolkien.
> They were all unharmed after battle, and there was noone how was brave
> enough to stop them! Èoemr should have at least one good Special Rule
> (+stats of Gothmog).
> I think that Èomer has strong will, he resisted powers of Saruman,
> he was
> banished from Rohan by his dear uncle, but he understood.
> And why 3 fates? He was Rohans most able commander as I said above,
> and he
> survived and fought every large battle at the war of the Ring (except
> before
> Lonely Mountain).
> And whu three attacks? Commanders, such as Gothmog, Dain, Aragorn,
> Imrahil
> and so on has all 3 attacks! I think that Rohans best hero should have
> three
> attacks too, he´s cut countless orcs down (in a movie he used his shield
> for
> that!).
> And why three wounds? Èomer was quite young, and he´s trained by
> experience
> and Théoden and Théodred and Èomund. Èomund was a mighty warror who
> fought
> ´til death! I think he wanted to his son become same. Young strong man
> should have high stamina. And imagine, fight your whole life and have a
> father like Èomund! And riding a horse and shooting same time (and
> fighting!) is not easy for a weak man.
> Is it too much to give Rohan one good and expensive hero?
> You think he´s good, but players don´t! Or am I only one.
>
> And what becomes of Elrond. He fought in a TLA as a Gil-galads
> herald and
> commanded his troops from frontline.
> He fought every great battle in TLA. In Dagorlad, before black gate and
> within a dark land itself!
> When Sauron attacked Gwaith-i-Mírdain and slew Celebrimor, son of
> Curufin,
> grandson of Fëanor, Gil-galad sent Elrond to fight Sauron and to
> gather all
> those who survived.
> Elrond fought there against Sauron and survived and found a beautiful
> valley
> of Imladris.
> Elrond is a son of mighty Eärendil the Mariner, who slew Ancalagon the
> Black, who was son of Tuor and Idril and they were daughter and son of
> Turgon and Huor, Turgon was son of Fingolfin and Huor was son of Galdor,
> son
> of Hador Lórindol!
> Elrond was a bearer of Vilya after Gil-galads death at hands of Sauron!
> Elrond was trained by Maedhros and Maglor, before those two passed away
> with
> Simarils.
> Great blood runs in Elronds veins (spelling wrong?).
> I think that those are good explanations, why Elrond should have at
> least F
> of 7 and some Special Rule!
> Elrond was a great healer, he cured Frodo from his terrible wound
> caused by
> Witch King at Amon Hen. He reigned long and stayed until the era of
> men!
> Now Elrond cannot even match Aragorn, who is mighty indeed, but
> still only
> a
> man. Elrond is more mightier than Aragorn. Elrond should have a
> couple good
> Special Rule, for Hadhafang the Sword and for healing for example. And
> maybe
> +1 free will/turn.
> For hadhafang (or just Elrond himself) something like "if outnumbered by
> two
> to one or more the enemies take a courage test. If failed, they
> counts as
> armed with daggers"
>
> There was a couple of reasons for Elrond. Now Witch King.
>
> Firstly, it is said that no mortal man can kill Witch King. Now a
> normal
> Warrior of Minas Tirith can do that!
> To avoid such a stupid losses, WK should have at least 2 wounds, maybe
> three.
> Withc King was most terrifying of all creatures (and creature he
> is!) and
> orcs would have killed themselves if WK has told them to.
> He fought against Cirdan and descendants of Elendil in Arnor (or
> somewhere
> near) and killed King Eärnil II in a duel.
> No mortal man can kill him, said Glorfindel and it was no mortal man
> who
> killed him.
> He was strong enough to confront Gandalf the maia, propably most
> powerful
> being in Middle-Earth.
> In a movie (or in Extended Edition) WK will break Gandalfs staff.
> There are couple of reasons.
> He has only 1 wound and 1 attack, so a normal elf can wipe him out if
> you´re
> unfortunate.
> A normal man if you´re very unforunate.
>
> And what becomes Faramir, he should have will of 3.
> He resisted a bad influence of the Ring and let Frodo go.
> He was able read from Gandalf what he has in his mind eventhough
> Gandalf
> didn´t tell anything. I think thats willpower.
> He has boldly served Gondor, eventhough Denethor didn´t keep in a good
> value
> and he was always second to Boromir.
> Denethors comment in SoG book is good to tell what Faramir has
> standed. "Do
> not trouble me with Faramir. I know his uses and they are few".
> Still, after all that Faramir gallantly served Gondor and did his
> best to
> save Gondor.
>
> I hope that you read this through, there are couple of reasons.
Jees, ja tästä ovat vielä turhat muodollisuudet jätetty pois. Nuo viivat tai mitä ihmeen nuolia ovat tulivat sen mailin mukana.
Ja tähän GW laittoi, että tunnun tietävän todella paljon LotRin taustoja, jonka jälkeen ne antoivat Alession ja Mattin osoitteen ja pyysivät lähettämään haluamani statit ja selitykset niille sinne.
Lähetin postia takaisin ja kysyin, että riittävätkö yllä olevat selitykset.
Ne vastasivat että todella varmasti, ja että Mattin ja Alession pitäisi reagoida niihin.